BLOG

The difference between a human coach and an AI agent
2026-03-04

A client recently said, “A mediocre coach is the same as ChatGPT. A good coach can really improve my quality of life.”

Her comment got me thinking about the differences between a human coach and an AI agent. I wrote many paragraphs to think it through, eventually creating a short philosophical treatise on the trivial question of what it means to be human.

After a while, I realized that the difference is simple and obvious:

AI’s goal is to get you to stop thinking. But the best coaches push you to think, relentlessly.

The limited utility of AI
AI is great at giving prescriptive advice.

For example, in my business, sometimes clients are late at paying their invoices. This is roughly what I want to convey:

“Please pay me soon, because it’ll save both you and me time if I stop chasing you. Unless you’ve changed your mind about working together, in which case don’t pay me, but at least tell me. Although probably you haven’t changed your mind and just forgot, which is totally fine. kthxbye.”

I don’t want a message about logistics to overflow with my insecurities as a fledgling business owner. I also don’t want to confuse the shit out of my client. So I'll ask AI to translate my gist into professional-ese:

“Hi - checking in as we are now past our official start date of February 1st. I’m excited to dive in, but I want to make sure we have the foundation set so you get the most out of our sessions. Please prioritize these three items today so we can officially kick off:...”

The point is that I’d run out of ideas, and then AI gave me an idea, which I implemented, and now I feel more confident about future communications about overdue invoices.

This is no different from looking up a list of action verbs to make your resume punchier, or reading a textbook on how to negotiate like a boss, or consulting a dictionary for the Italian word for pain. Books, webinars, AI, podcasts, teachers — they’re delivering information in a one-way flow. If all you need is information, and you’re certain about the exact bit of information you’re searching for, then look it up on AI. Don’t waste your time and money on a coach.

(By the way, most coaches, or any expert for that matter, who’ve been in the business long enough will have dumped their know-how into webinars, workbooks, books, courses, or an AI agent anyways, specifically because they also don’t want to waste their own time and potential impact by repeating the same thing over and over.)

Be careful what you outsource
But is lack of information ever the main obstacle to our living the lives that we value?

As Derek Sivers said, "If more information was the answer, then we'd all be billionaires with perfect abs.""

What do you do with the aforementioned information? That’s usually where we get tripped up. In this terrifying article about “agency” as a hot word in Silicon Valley at the moment, the author interviews this guy named Scott Alexander, who summed up the situation with AI neatly,

“Many of these people are smart enough that they could answer their own questions, but they want someone else to do it, because then they don’t have to have this terrifying encounter with their own humanity.”

Because beyond the easy-to-answer questions (who do I need to talk to in order to figure out whether I'll like this job? how do I delegate my current workload so that I can focus on building a new part of the business?) lie the deeper questions for which there is no right answer.

Questions like: How do you major in computer science and then get a job in the food industry? How do you quit being a teacher for ten years and then get into restaurant marketing? How do you start another company when you're traumatized from how hard it was the first time around? How do you stay at your C-suite job and make it more fulfilling? How do you feed your creativity, which also gets you the paycheck, when you’re growing a child or splitting up from your partner?

There are a gajillion ways. And there is no right way.

Sure, I give tried-and-true tips and strategies, and I’m an efficient way to deliver you the info if you don’t have time to personally read a lot of books about practical life and management philosophy. I might even have unique personal experience and wisdom that you can't find anywhere else because I specialize in career moves that shouldn't work but somehow work. But that’s still only about 20% of the coaching.

The other 80% is about me holding my tongue and forging the inviolate container in which someone can, perhaps for the first time in a long time, think. Clearly, deeply, selfishly, honestly. You cannot outsource your thinking here. I won’t let you.

And therein lies the terrifying encounter with our own humanity. My mission is to help you confront that. You might discover that the terrible perhaps isn’t so terrifying. And beyond that, you might get to meet the beautiful, the oddball, the true, the ugly, the delightful, the sad. After you do all that, and you’re still standing, then you know you can do anything. You won’t need me, nor an AI, or your best friend to validate you during happy hour. That is what a good coach can do.